SV

Street Verdict

Analyst Scorecard

Building a portfolio

Lesson 8.11 · about 14 minutes

Sequence of returns and behavioural traps

  • Hypothetical
  • Long history

Learn to

  • See why the order of returns matters when money is taken out
  • Name loss aversion, recency, herd behaviour, overconfidence and anchoring
  • Spot each habit in a short statement

Ideas in this lesson

  • Sequence of returns
  • Withdrawal rate
  • Loss aversion
  • Recency
  • Herd behaviour
  • Overconfidence
  • Anchoring

Two people can earn the same average return and finish in different places if they take money out. Sequence of returns is the order in which returns arrive. A bad run early, while the pot is large compared with the withdrawals, does more damage than the same run late, because withdrawals leave less money to recover.

Below, two hypothetical retirees get the same ten yearly returns in opposite order. The returns are invented, chosen only to make the point. This lesson names no withdrawal rate as sensible, because that depends on a person's whole situation and belongs with a registered adviser.

Behaviour matters as much as arithmetic. Five habits are widely described in behavioural finance: loss aversion (a loss hurts more than an equal gain pleases), recency (the last few months feel like the future), herd behaviour (doing what others are doing), overconfidence and anchoring (clinging to a number such as the price paid).

The round below shows eight short statements from invented people. Sort each by the habit it shows. A real market episode frames them: the numbers for the 2020 fall and recovery come from the data (past, not forecast).

Try it · invented returns for illustration; the market episode is past data

Set an opening amount and a yearly withdrawal, then compare the two retirees. After that, sort the statements.

Two retirees, the same ten yearly returns in opposite order

Invented returns for illustration. Each year: the withdrawal comes out at the start, then that year’s return applies to what is left.

Yearly returns, in order for Retiree 1: −18%, −8%, +4%, +12%, +20%, +16%, +9%, +14%, +6%, +11%. Retiree 2 gets the same list backwards.

₹100 lakh
6%
  • Retiree 1 (bad years first)
  • Retiree 2 (good years first)
₹100L₹150LYear 0Year 2Year 4Year 6Year 8Year 10

Average yearly return, both

6.6%

steady equivalent 6.0%

Retiree 1 ends with

₹74,19,313

Retiree 2 ends with

₹1,08,22,677

With no withdrawals, both end with

₹1,78,83,498

the same amount

No withdrawal share on this slider is suggested. The slider exists to show that the gap between the two appears only when money is taken out.

Spot the habit

Loading the long-history data…

  1. “I sold in March 2020 because the last three weeks looked like a trend that would not stop.”

  2. “I will not sell until it gets back to what I paid, whatever else changes.”

  3. “Everyone in my office is buying this, so I am putting money in too.”

  4. “I have been right three times in a row, so I can raise my position safely.”

  5. “Losing ₹10,000 ruined my week, but gaining ₹10,000 barely registered.”

  6. “It rose strongly last month, so it will clearly keep doing that.”

  7. “The forum is full of people saying this is the moment, so I assume they know.”

  8. “I know this sector better than the professionals, so I do not need to check the numbers.”

0 of 8 right so far.

With no withdrawals the two end in exactly the same place: order does not matter when nothing is taken out. With withdrawals it does. Sequence risk is one reason people often consider the timing of withdrawals when they plan, and a registered adviser can model a real case.

The habits are not flaws of other people. They show up in everyone, and a written rule made in calm times is one common way people try to keep a mood from deciding. Which rule, if any, is personal.

Check yourself

0 of 3 right

  1. 1. Same average return, opposite order, withdrawals each year. Who ends with more?
  2. 2. Someone stays out of the market after a fall because “it will keep falling”. Which habit is closest?
  3. 3. A person will not act until a price returns to what they paid. This is closest to:

Answer every question correctly to complete this lesson.

A personal question?This lesson teaches a method and shows arithmetic on invented numbers or past data. It does not know your situation. For a question about your own money, ask a SEBI-registered investment adviser; SEBI keeps a searchable list of registered intermediaries, its Recognised Intermediaries search.

Sources

Last reviewed 30 Oct 2026 by the author. Independent fact review is pending before public launch. Facts are as of the dates shown. Education only; not investment advice.