SV

Street Verdict

Analyst Scorecard

Building a portfolio

Lesson 8.13 · about 14 minutes

Reviewing a portfolio

  • Hypothetical

Learn to

  • List what people often check in a review: mix, costs, overlap, concentration and changed goals
  • Tell absolute return, CAGR and XIRR apart, and say when each fits
  • Say why comparing a mixed portfolio with one index is an unfair test

Ideas in this lesson

  • Absolute return
  • CAGR
  • XIRR
  • Benchmark choice
  • Review cadence
  • Over-checking

A review is a list of questions, asked on a schedule, about what is there now. People often start with: what is the mix across classes, what does it cost each year, do the holdings overlap, how large is the largest holding, and have the goals or dates changed since the portfolio was built. The X-ray below prints these as plain percentages and passes no verdict.

Three return measures answer different questions. Absolute return is the total gain as a percentage of what was put in. CAGR is the steady yearly rate that links a start value and an end value, and fits a single lump sum. XIRR handles money put in or taken out on different dates, so it fits regular contributions.

A benchmark is a yardstick. A portfolio that holds several classes cannot fairly be compared with one index that holds only shares: they do different jobs, so the gap says little about skill. A fairer yardstick matches the mix, and building one is a task for an adviser.

People often review on a schedule, once or twice a year, and after a big change in life. Looking daily pulls attention to noise, and over-checking is itself a common trap. The X-ray starts on a sample hypothetical portfolio. You may type your own figures; they stay in your browser and nothing is sent anywhere.

Try it · hypothetical data

Read the sample portfolio's X-ray. To use your own figures, edit the table. You can clear it with one button.

A sample hypothetical portfolio

Invented holdings. Edit any cell to use your own figures.

HoldingKindValue now (₹)Yearly cost (%)Put in (₹)Years held

Figures you type stay in this browser (local storage) and are never sent. Nothing on this page makes a network request. Clear removes them.

The X-ray: what the figures say, in plain percentages

Total value: ₹15,00,000.

Shares of companies: 16.7% of the total (₹2,50,000).

Funds that own shares: 40.0% of the total (₹6,00,000).

Bonds and bond funds: 20.0% of the total (₹3,00,000).

Gold: 10.0% of the total (₹1,50,000).

Cash and deposits: 13.3% of the total (₹2,00,000).

  • Number of holdings: 5.
  • The largest single holding, Holding 1, is 40.0% of the total.
  • The three largest holdings together are 76.7% of the total.
  • Average yearly cost, weighted by amount: 0.30% of the value, about ₹4,500 a year.
  • Holding 1: put in ₹4,50,000, now ₹6,00,000; absolute return 33.3%; as a single lump sum held 5 years, CAGR 5.9% a year.
  • Holding 2: put in ₹2,80,000, now ₹3,00,000; absolute return 7.1%; as a single lump sum held 3 years, CAGR 2.3% a year.
  • Holding 3: put in ₹1,00,000, now ₹1,50,000; absolute return 50.0%; as a single lump sum held 4 years, CAGR 10.7% a year.
  • Holding 4: put in ₹1,90,000, now ₹2,00,000; absolute return 5.3%; as a single lump sum held 2 years, CAGR 2.6% a year.
  • Holding 5: put in ₹1,80,000, now ₹2,50,000; absolute return 38.9%; as a single lump sum held 6 years, CAGR 5.6% a year.
  • All of the above together: put in ₹12,00,000, now ₹15,00,000; absolute return 25.0%.

56.7% of this portfolio is in shares of companies or funds that own shares; an index of company shares describes only that part.

A share index describes only the class of large-company shares. The part of this portfolio outside that class is not compared with anything by an index of shares.

Total entered: ₹15,00,000. The lines describe the figures typed above and say nothing about whether the figures fit anyone’s situation.

Three return measures on the same money

Dated amounts: money put in is negative, money out or the final value is positive. The sample is invented.

DateAmount (₹, negative = put in)
  • Absolute return: 20.0% on ₹3,00,000 put in, whenever it went in.
  • CAGR if all the money had gone in on the first date: 6.3% a year over 3.0 years. It ignores that later amounts were invested for less time.
  • XIRR, which weighs each amount by its own dates: 9.4% a year.

The X-ray does not say whether a portfolio is good or bad, and it will not: a percentage describes, while judging needs a goal and a person. For a review of actual holdings, ask a SEBI-registered adviser, who can see the whole picture and is accountable for what they say.

If you typed your own figures, they are held in this browser only, in local storage, and the clear button removes them. Closing the page does not send them anywhere, because nothing in this lesson makes a network request.

Check yourself

0 of 3 right

  1. 1. Why is comparing a mixed portfolio with the Nifty 50 an unfair test?
  2. 2. Money was put in on several different dates. Which return measure fits?
  3. 3. ₹1 lakh grew to ₹1.6 lakh over 4 years as one lump sum. Which measure gives the steady yearly rate?

Answer every question correctly to complete this lesson.

A personal question?This lesson teaches a method and shows arithmetic on invented numbers or past data. It does not know your situation. For a question about your own money, ask a SEBI-registered investment adviser; SEBI keeps a searchable list of registered intermediaries, its Recognised Intermediaries search.

Sources

Last reviewed 30 Oct 2026 by the author. Independent fact review is pending before public launch. Facts are as of the dates shown. Education only; not investment advice.