Lesson 8.4 · about 12 minutes
Allocation: the trade-off, not the answer
- Long history
Learn to
- Read how two mixes changed the range of 1, 3 and 5 year outcomes in the past
- Explain the trade-off between the upper end of results and the deepest fall
- Say why a mix is a statement about the future that history cannot settle
Ideas in this lesson
- Asset allocation
- Risk-return trade-off
- Time horizon
- Glide path
- Mix versus selection
Asset allocation is the split of a pot between classes: equity, bonds, gold and cash. Researchers argue about how much of a fund's results come from its split compared with the holdings picked inside it, and the answer depends on what is measured. This lesson does not settle that debate. It shows what the split did to the range of results in the data we have.
The real series here are daily closes from 1 January 2016 to 31 December 2025: the Nifty 50 price index (dividends are not included), NSE's Nifty 10 yr Benchmark G-Sec Index (a total return index for the 10-year government bond) and the price of an NSE-listed gold exchange-traded fund. Cash is an invented steady 4% a year, because we have no published cash series. All of it is past, not forecast.
Below, two hypothetical mixes, Mix A and Mix B, run through every start day in the data. For 1, 3 and 5 years the table shows the middle, lowest and highest yearly result among all the windows, and the deepest fall from a high. Each mix is reset to its set split once a year with no costs. Neither is a suggestion: they start with different splits only so the table has something to compare, and every slider can be moved.
There is a trade-off between the upper end of results and the deepest fall, and no row marks one mix as the answer. Which split suits a person depends on a goal, a date and a tolerance for falls that only the person can supply.
Try it · past data to 31 December 2025; cash is invented
Set the split for Mix A and Mix B. The table shows past results for every start day.
The two mixes start with different splits only so the table has something to compare. They are not suggestions.
Loading the long-history data…
Two things history cannot tell you. First, the future need not repeat this decade: gold rose strongly in this data, which nobody can count on again. Second, the middle result is the middle of overlapping windows from one path of history, not what a typical person experienced.
A glide path is the idea that people often change their split as a goal date nears, because capacity to absorb a fall shrinks as the date approaches. Whether and how is a personal matter. Lesson 8.8 shows what the falls were like along the way.
Check yourself
0 of 3 right
Answer every question correctly to complete this lesson.
Sources
Last reviewed 30 Oct 2026 by the author. Independent fact review is pending before public launch. Facts are as of the dates shown. Education only; not investment advice.