Lesson 7.5 · about 12 minutes
Time frames, stated targets, stops and the three buckets
- News or record
- Hypothetical
Learn to
- See how a missing or moving time frame makes a call impossible to prove wrong
- Explain why the close, not the day's high, decides whether a stated target was reached
- Sort a statement into Trackable, Long-Horizon or Commentary and say why
Ideas in this lesson
- Stated window
- Closing versus intraday
- Moving goalposts
- Never-triggered setups
- Ungradable commentary
Every call in this lesson is a past call that has already been graded. It is here to practise reading and judging, not as a view on any stock.
A call becomes checkable when it has a stated target, a stop and a time frame. Remove the time frame and nobody can say when to judge it. Move the time frame after the price has gone the other way (“it was always a long-term call”) and the call can never be wrong. Judge a stated target by the day's high instead of the close and almost any call looks right, because prices wander through many levels in one day.
Street Verdict grades on closing prices only. A price that touches a stated target during the day but closes below it has not reached that stated target on a close, and a wick through a stop is not a stop-out. The window is the one the call implies itself (“the next two weeks”). A call with a stated target and no time frame is given a default window by the grader: that is an assumption of ours, not the analyst's word.
Every opinion we store then goes into one of three buckets. Trackable calls name an instrument we have price history for and state a claim specific enough to check against it: a stated target, a level, or a plain directional view with a window. Long-Horizon views have a horizon of years, so no near-term check applies. Commentary is general market colour or a macro view with no price call. Only Trackable calls are scored.
Try it · invented examples, then a real graded call
Move the window on an invented price path, then sort eight invented statements into the three buckets.
The same call, three verdicts
An invented price path, the same for every reader. The call: the price starts at 200, the stated target is 212 and the stop is 188.
Solid dot: the first close at or above the stated target. Hollow dot: the first day's high that touched it.
Graded on closing prices (the site's rule)
A miss
The 30-day window ended without a close reaching the stated target.
If the day's high counted
A miss
The 30-day window ended without a day's high reaching the stated target.
Which bucket?
“Stock A to ₹250 in the next three weeks, with a stop at ₹218.”
“Stock C can double over the next five years as its capacity comes on stream.”
“The market feels nervous and could go either way.”
“Stock B to close above ₹480 this month.”
“Inflation data next week matters for banks.”
“Stock D should be worth ₹900 by March 2029.”
“Banking looks interesting here.”
“Stock E to ₹1,250 by the end of next month, stop at ₹1,090.”
0 of 8 right so far.
Loading real graded calls…
On the invented path above, a 50-day window ends with the stated target not reached on a close. The path does close above it on day 59, and its intraday highs touch it on day 43. One call, three different verdicts, decided only by the rules for time and for what counts as reaching a level. That is why the rules are written down on the methodology page before any call is graded.
Two more ways a call escapes judgement. A setup that waits for an entry level (“enter only above 100”) that the price never reaches did not trigger: it is neither a hit nor a miss, and it counts toward nobody's score. A statement with no instrument, level or window (“banks look interesting”) is Commentary. It can be quoted for years because it can never be tested.
When you meet a call, find the time frame first. If there is none, ask what window would be fair, and whether the verdict changes with a different one.
Check yourself
0 of 3 right
Answer every question correctly to complete this lesson.
Open it live
Lessons use prices at least 30 days old. The live pages show current ones.
Sources
Last reviewed 30 Oct 2026 by the author. Independent fact review is pending before public launch. Facts are as of the dates shown. Education only; not investment advice.