SV

Street Verdict

Analyst Scorecard

Judging market advice

Lesson 7.4 · about 12 minutes

The baseline

  • News or record

Learn to

  • Compare a call with NIFTY 50 over the same window
  • Explain why a rising market flatters bullish calls
  • Read a base rate before reading a hit rate

Ideas in this lesson

  • Benchmark
  • Same-direction base rate
  • Market drift
  • Compared with what

Every call in this lesson is a past call that has already been graded. It is here to practise reading and judging, not as a view on any stock.

A result means little without something to compare it with. For a call, the simplest comparison is the market itself: what did NIFTY 50 do over the same window? We store that move beside every graded call, from the day the grading entered the call.

Two facts shape the picture. Almost all tracked calls are bullish. And over most one-month windows NIFTY 50 went up. So a bullish call has a head start: the market was moving the way the call said even if the call added nothing. That head start is the baseline.

Below, the same graded calls are shown with and without the baseline. The counts come from the calls that qualify for this track.

Try it

Switch the baseline on and off, and look at calls beside NIFTY 50 over the same window.

Loading real graded calls…

Loading real graded calls…

How big the baseline's effect is depends on the sample, and the box above says what this sample shows, in words built from its own counts. What matters is that a hit rate quoted without a baseline, in a market that mostly rose, cannot be read.

The simple base rate shown here is the share of windows in which NIFTY 50 itself moved the way the call said. It is a market-wide stand-in. A fuller baseline would ask how often a random call in the same direction on the same stock would have reached the same stated target, and we have not built that yet.

Check yourself

0 of 3 right

  1. 1. Most tracked calls are bullish and the market rose. Why does a 70% hit rate prove little?
  2. 2. What does the same-direction base rate measure?
  3. 3. A bearish call reached its stated target in a month when NIFTY 50 fell 6%. What is the fair reading?

Answer every question correctly to complete this lesson.

Lessons use prices at least 30 days old. The live pages show current ones.

Sources

Last reviewed 30 Oct 2026 by the author. Independent fact review is pending before public launch. Facts are as of the dates shown. Education only; not investment advice.