Lesson SH3 · about 8 minutes
Five questions for any claim
- Hypothetical
Learn to
- Break a claim into five questions
- Spot a missing baseline
- Tell a fact from a forecast and an opinion
Ideas in this lesson
- Claim
- Source and incentive
- Mechanism
- Size of the effect
- Baseline
Most claims about money fit in one sentence, and most of that sentence is missing something. Five questions fill in what is missing.
1. What exactly is claimed? A number, a direction and a date, or only a mood? 2. Who says it, and what do they gain? An analyst, a seller of a product, a friend? 3. What is the mechanism? Why would this happen? 4. How big could the effect be? Rupees, not adjectives. 5. Compared with what? Every return should be set beside a baseline, such as the market index over the same dates.
Three kinds of statement hide in the same sentence. A fact can be checked (“the company reported a profit of ₹X”). A forecast is a claim about the future, which can only be graded later. An opinion is a judgement (“a strong business”) that cannot be graded at all. Good practice is to separate them before you decide how much weight each deserves.
Try it · hypothetical data
Read the hypothetical call, answer the five questions, then see what happened.
“Bullish on Alpha Foods Ltd. Target ₹1,200 in twelve months, about 20% above today's ₹1,000.”
On this site, calls are graded the same way: against closing prices, with the market beside them. See how at /methodology. The example above is invented; real calls are shown only once their window has closed.
Check yourself
0 of 2 right
Answer every question correctly to complete this lesson.
Open it live
Lessons use prices at least 30 days old. The live pages show current ones.
Sources
Last reviewed 28 Oct 2026 by the author. Independent fact review is pending before public launch. Facts are as of the dates shown. Education only; not investment advice.