SV

Street Verdict

Analyst Scorecard

All of Learn

Testing an idea 2: reading results

Drawdown, win rate, Sharpe, walk-forward: what each number means and when a result is too good to be true.

0 of 9 done

All modulesModule 3 of 9

Win rate vs payoff

Slide the win rate and the sizes of wins and losses, roll 100 trades, and see why a 35% win rate can make money while 80% can lose.

Do this first

Set the odds, roll 100 trades

Three numbers decide whether a way of trading makes money: how often it wins (the win rate), how much a typical win makes and how much a typical loss costs. Try the presets, then roll the dice a few times.

35%
₹3,000
₹1,000

Average result per trade

+₹400

expectancy

Win rate needed to break even

25%

you have 35%

Expected after 100 trades

+₹40,000

Chance of being ahead after 100

98%

exact, not simulated

This run: 38 wins of 100 (38%), ended +₹52,000, longest losing run 8.

  • Average expectation
  • This run
₹0₹25k₹50k₹75kBreak evenStartTrade 20Trade 40Trade 60Trade 80Trade 100

The bold line is one run of 100 trades; the grey ones are 19 more with the same odds. Each trade wins exactly the average win or loses exactly the average loss, before costs. Real trades vary in size, which only adds to the spread.

Read it

Win rate means nothing without payoff

The average win divided by the average loss is the payoff ratio. Together with the win rate it gives the expectancy, the average result per trade:

win rate × average win − loss rate × average loss = 35% × ₹3,000 − 65% × ₹1,000 = +₹400

A trend-following strategy typically wins rarely and big: it loses small amounts on many false starts and makes its money on a few long trends. A strategy that sells options or takes quick profits often wins most of the time and small, and then gives it all back in one bad loss. A high win rate feels good and says nothing on its own.

The 80% trap.At an 80% win rate, wins of ₹500 and losses of ₹2,500 lose ₹100 a trade on average, and after 100 trades you are behind about 81% of the time. At a 35% win rate with wins three times the losses, you are ahead about 98% of the time.

Try it

Losing streaks are normal

Even a profitable way of trading strings losses together. At a 35% win rate, each trade loses with a 65% chance, and over 100 trades long runs of losses are not a sign that something broke. Plan for them before they happen.

6

Chance of at least one run of 6 or more losses in 100 trades: 96%. The longest losing run to expect is about 9.

~100%
2
~100%
3
~100%
4
~100%
5
96%
6
85%
7
69%
8
52%
9
37%
10
25%
11
17%
12

Bars: chance of a losing run at least that long (2 to 12) in 100 trades, worked out exactly from the win rate.

Check yourself

0 of 3 right

  1. 1. Wins average ₹3,000, losses average ₹1,000, and you win 35% of trades. Average result per trade?

  2. 2. Wins average ₹1,000 and losses average ₹1,000. What win rate do you need just to break even (before costs)?

  3. 3. Your strategy wins 40% of trades. Over 100 trades, a run of 7 losses in a row is…