SV

Street Verdict

Analyst Scorecard

All of Learn

Testing an idea 2: reading results

Drawdown, win rate, Sharpe, walk-forward: what each number means and when a result is too good to be true.

0 of 9 done

A backtest is a story about the past, and it is easy to tell yourself a flattering one. These nine short modules run real backtests on real NSE prices, through the same engine as the workbench and the Strategy Lab, and show you how to read every number, and how to catch a result that is too good to be true. Each one starts with something to do, and ends with a two- or three-question check.

The stock the modules run on (change it any time):

EMA 20/50 crossover, last 5 years of daily NSE prices, ₹1,00,000 per trade, real delivery charges and 0.03% slippage.

Start with module 1
  1. Your first result, annotatedRun a real backtest on a stock you pick and read every number in plain words, with a note on whether it is any good.
  2. Equity curve and drawdownHover the account's value day by day, see the worst fall from a high, how long it took to recover, and why losses hurt more than gains help.
  3. Win rate vs payoffSlide the win rate and the sizes of wins and losses, roll 100 trades, and see why a 35% win rate can make money while 80% can lose.
  4. Costs: ideal vs realThe same result with and without charges and slippage, and how trading more often widens the gap.
  5. Beating buy-and-holdPut the strategy next to simply holding the stock and the NIFTY 50, and see what being out of the market costs and saves.
  6. Risk-adjusted return (Sharpe)Two curves end in the same place; one is a smooth climb, the other a rollercoaster. See what the Sharpe ratio captures and what it misses.
  7. OverfittingTry 50 settings on the early years, keep the top scorer, then see how it did on the later years it never saw. Repeat on several stocks.
  8. Walk-forward and Monte CarloRe-choose settings month by month using only the past, and reshuffle a strategy's trades thousands of times to see the spread of outcomes.
  9. Is this result good? A checklistTake a result, yours or one from here, through seven checks: trades, costs, buy-and-hold, drawdown, unseen data, future-peeking and other stocks.