Lesson 6.4 · about 12 minutes
Noise versus signal
- Past prices, at least 30 days old
- Hypothetical
Learn to
- Know how big an ordinary day is for an index
- Spot an after-the-fact explanation
- Ask how often something happens before asking why it happened
Ideas in this lesson
- Volatility
- Base rate
- Noise
- Hindsight bias
- Attribution
An index moves a little almost every day. How big is an ordinary day? A base rate answers that: of all the days in a long enough history, how many had a move larger than a given size? Without the base rate a 1% move can look like a shock when it may be an ordinary event. A move inside the usual range is noise. A change large and lasting enough to stand out from it is what people mean by a signal.
After a big day, headlines explain it. The trouble with an explanation written afterwards is that hindsight makes any story seem natural, and the same set of reasons could have been written whichever way the index went. A test of an explanation is whether anyone wrote it down before. The second block shows three explanations built for the biggest day in the history, written for an up day and for a down day.
Try it · past index levels and constructed headlines
Move the threshold and read how often the Nifty 50 moved by more than that in a day. Then switch between an up day and a down day and read the explanations that would be written for each.
Loading index history...
The histogram counts sessions by the size of the day's move over the history the lessons may show. The shape matters more than any single bar: most days are small, and the large ones are rare but not unheard of.
The headlines in the second block are our constructed examples. They are not quotes from real publications. They are built from the common kinds of explanation, which are global cues, foreign investors and crude oil, and each can be turned round to fit either direction.
Check yourself
0 of 3 right
Answer every question correctly to complete this lesson.
Open it live
Lessons use prices at least 30 days old. The live pages show current ones.
Sources
Last reviewed 30 Oct 2026 by the author. Independent fact review is pending before public launch. Facts are as of the dates shown. Education only; not investment advice.