SV

Street Verdict

Analyst Scorecard

Money basics

Lesson 1.6 · about 14 minutes

SIPs: what averaging does and does not do

  • Hypothetical

Learn to

  • Run a SIP on a long history
  • See how the start date changes the outcome
  • Question the claim that SIPs always win

Ideas in this lesson

  • Rupee-cost averaging
  • Lump sum versus SIP
  • XIRR
  • Sequence of returns

A SIP, a systematic investment plan, puts a fixed amount into a fund every month. Because the amount is fixed, it buys more units when the price is low and fewer when it is high. That effect is called rupee-cost averaging.

Averaging smooths the price you pay on average. It does not guarantee a gain, and it does not remove losses. A fund that keeps falling for years loses money on a SIP too.

How the result varies with the start date is the real lesson. The tool below runs the same SIP from every start month in a hypothetical market and plots the spread of outcomes, measured as a yearly return (XIRR).

Try it · hypothetical data

Choose how long the SIP runs and the month it starts. The market is hypothetical: invented and seeded, not real index data.

month 24

Paid in (₹10,000 a month)

₹6,00,000

Worth at the end

₹9,31,764

Yearly return (XIRR)

17.6%

Across every start month

-19% to 40%

240 start months

-12%9%30%your start 18%

Each bar counts start months. The highlighted bar holds the one you picked.

5001000your SIPMonth 0Month 60Month 120Month 180Month 240Month 300
Hypothetical market:Invented and seeded, so every reader sees the same history. It is not real index data and says nothing about the future.

Look at the shape of the spread, not one bar. Two people who started a few years apart can end far apart, with the same amount invested and the same monthly discipline. Part of that is luck of timing, called sequence of returns.

This market comes from a simple random model with a rising trend and large swings, so the spread is an illustration of the idea. Real index history needs a licensed dataset, which we have not added yet. When we do, this tool will run on it.

Check yourself

0 of 3 right

  1. 1. Two SIPs of the same amount start five years apart. Why can their results differ widely?
  2. 2. What does rupee-cost averaging do?
  3. 3. A chart shows a SIP that earned a high return in one window. What is the useful next question?

Answer every question correctly to complete this lesson.

A personal question?This lesson teaches a method and shows arithmetic on invented numbers or past data. It does not know your situation. For a question about your own money, ask a SEBI-registered investment adviser; SEBI keeps a searchable list of registered intermediaries, its Recognised Intermediaries search.

Sources

Last reviewed 28 Oct 2026 by the author. Independent fact review is pending before public launch. Facts are as of the dates shown. Education only; not investment advice.