SV

Street Verdict

Analyst Scorecard

Reading a company

Lesson 3.8 · about 14 minutes

Red flags, with cases

  • Company filing
  • Hypothetical

Learn to

  • Run a short checklist of questions on a company's own numbers
  • See how warning signs can build up over years in a filing
  • Treat every flag as a question to read about, not a verdict

Ideas in this lesson

  • Cash against profit
  • Customer dues growth
  • Rising debt
  • Interest cover
  • One-off items
  • Auditor changes
  • Restatements

The company is the one you pick, and its figures are its own annual filings, the same ones its page on this site shows. Nothing here is a view on any company.

Companies that later ran into trouble often showed signs in their own filings years earlier. The signs prove nothing. Plenty of healthy companies show one of them for a good reason. A red flag is a question to ask, answered by reading the notes, and not a finding.

The usual ones: profit that keeps running ahead of cash; customer dues growing faster than sales; borrowing rising faster than equity; interest taking most of operating profit; frequent “exceptional” items; a change of auditor or an auditor's qualification; restated past figures; promoter shares pledged and rising; and “adjusted” profit measures that differ a lot from reported profit.

The three case files below are invented to show how the signs build over time. They are labelled hypothetical on purpose: a real company can be named in a lesson only when a final SEBI or court order stands behind the story, and each such case needs a legal read first.

Try it · invented examples and real filings

Read the three invented case files, then run the checks on a company you pick.

Three invented case files

Each company is invented. Step through the years, say what you would ask, then see where to look.

Case A: profit that never became cash

A maker of industrial equipment, invented for this lesson. Revenue grew about 20% a year for three years.

  1. Year 1: profit ₹100 crore, cash from operations ₹95 crore, customer dues ₹300 crore on revenue of ₹1,200 crore.

    Is cash following profit?

Case B: borrowing that outran earnings

A builder of roads, invented for this lesson. It won large contracts in Year 1.

  1. Year 1: borrowings ₹400 crore, equity ₹500 crore, operating profit ₹120 crore, interest ₹40 crore.

    How comfortable is interest cover?

Case C: profit helped by one-offs

A chemicals maker, invented for this lesson. Revenue is flat across the years.

  1. Year 1: revenue ₹800 crore, operating profit ₹120 crore, exceptional gain ₹0, profit after tax ₹70 crore.

    What is the baseline?

Run the checks on a company you pick

These are questions, not findings. Each check says what the numbers show and, if it raises a question, where to read next.

Pick any company

The five names are in alphabetical order and are only there because their filings are large, complete and in the plain layout. Nothing here is a view on any company. Your choice stays in this browser.

Loading ASIANPAINT…

The checks on your company use only the lines we carry: cash from operations and profit, customer dues and revenue, borrowings and equity, interest, profit and revenue over the years, and the operating margin. A check that needs a missing line says so. The things we do not hold, such as an auditor change or a restatement, are in the annual report and the exchange announcements.

A check that raises a question is a reason to read. A result that raises none is not a clean bill of health, since the numbers can only show what the company reported.

Check yourself

0 of 3 right

  1. 1. In Case A, which two checks would have raised a question before the third year?
  2. 2. A check shows that debt to equity doubled. Is that a finding?
  3. 3. A company raises none of the checks. What can you conclude?

Answer every question correctly to complete this lesson.

A personal question?This lesson teaches a method and shows arithmetic on invented numbers or past data. It does not know your situation. For a question about your own money, ask a SEBI-registered investment adviser; SEBI keeps a searchable list of registered intermediaries, its Recognised Intermediaries search.

Lessons use prices at least 30 days old. The live pages show current ones.

Sources

Last reviewed 30 Oct 2026 by the author. Independent fact review is pending before public launch. Facts are as of the dates shown. Education only; not investment advice.