SV

Street Verdict

Analyst Scorecard

A record of what Jay Thakkar said publicly, with the source. Not advice.

“Bullish on Astral May futures for the short term, recommending a buy in the ₹1,370-₹1,390 range with a stop loss at ₹1,335. Targets are ₹1,460 and ₹1,500, as the stock has paused its downtrend and formed a base around ₹1,250 levels.”

Jay Thakkar’s track record (trackable calls only): 92 graded calls · 95% CI 40–60%

Astral LtdBullishCalled 23 Apr 2025Graded 02 May 2025
Verdict:MISS

How this call is judged

A call is judged on closing prices only: a close at its target is a hit and a close at its stop is a miss. A call that states an entry starts at the first close that reaches it; if none does in the days allowed, it was never triggered, is not graded and counts toward no hit rate.

Entry zone: ₹1,370–₹1,390. The call starts at the first close that comes into it.

Target ₹1,460, stop ₹1,335, as stated.

Window: 30 days, from the call's own horizon word ("for the short term").

The stop ₹1,335 was reached on a close before the target ₹1,460. Miss.

The grader’s working: R3 TRADE_SETUP: entered ₹1390 on 2025-04-25 (stated entry ₹1370–1390 zone, ZONE entry, filled); stop ₹1335 breached at close ₹1316.1 on 2025-05-02. Window 30 days — rule H4: the quote says "for the short term" (short-term 30 days, medium-term 90, long-term 12 months).

Tracking Astral Ltd since this call

1-year tracking window
Read the original articleSee Jay Thakkar’s full track record