SV

Street Verdict

Analyst Scorecard

A record of what Sharan Lillaney said publicly, with the source. Not advice.

“Bullish on Tata Steel with a target of ₹168 and a stop loss at ₹156. This recommendation is for a short-term trading idea.”

Sharan Lillaney’s track record (trackable calls only): 19 graded calls · 95% CI 9–43%

Tata SteelBullishCalled 21 Jul 2025Graded 01 Aug 2025
Verdict:MISS

How this call is judged

A call is judged on closing prices only: a close at its target is a hit and a close at its stop is a miss. A call that states an entry starts at the first close that reaches it; if none does in the days allowed, it was never triggered, is not graded and counts toward no hit rate. No time frame is stated and the call gives both a target and a stop, so it is tracked until a close reaches one of them (rule H6): the target first is a hit, the stop first a miss, and until then it stays open.

No entry price is stated, so the call starts at the first close after it was published.

Target ₹168, stop ₹156, as stated.

No time frame is stated, so it is tracked until a close reaches ₹168 or ₹156: there is no fixed window.

The stop ₹156 was reached on a close before the target ₹168. Miss.

The grader’s working: R4 TARGET_CALL: entered ₹163.04 on 2025-07-22 (next trading session's close); stop ₹156 breached at close ₹153.01 on 2025-08-01. No time frame is stated and the call gives both a target and a stop, so it is tracked until a close reaches one of them (rule H6): the target first is a hit, the stop first a miss, and until then it stays open.

How it played out

How this is worked out
Target or stop first
The stop was reached on a close before the target was.
Time to target
The target was not reached on a close before the stop was.
Worst close against it
The closing price went as far as 6.15% against the call up to 1 Aug 2025, when the call was decided, measured from the entry price. Closing prices only; an intraday dip is never counted.

From the entry the grade used, on closing prices. This is a record of one past call and is not advice.

Tracking Tata Steel since this call

1-year tracking window
Read the original articleSee Sharan Lillaney’s full track record