SV

Street Verdict

Analyst Scorecard

A record of what Pramod Gubbi said publicly, with the source. Not advice.

“Marcellus Investment Managers is becoming constructive on the market, having reduced smallcap cash from 40% to 13% as the recent correction brings valuations back to earth. They are selectively deploying into structurally sound but temporarily mispriced names, viewing current crises as prime buying opportunities, especially as the market shifts to rewarding genuine stock-picking. Gubbi is particularly bullish on HDFC Bank as a long-term buy at current levels, seeing its 15-18% correction as an attractive entry point given its strong asset quality and consistent earnings, expecting a rotation back to quality private banks over cyclical PSU banks. A key risk is a prolonged West Asia conflict leading to a full-blown energy crisis, which could deteriorate India's macro fundamentals.”
HDFC BankBullishCalled 13 Mar 2026Graded 21 Nov 2026
Verdict:MISS

How this relative call is judged

A relative call is a comparison, judged on closing prices from the first close after the call to the end of its window (3 months when the quote states no time frame). The spread is the pick's return minus the comparator's return: above zero is a hit for a call that favours the pick, and the reverse for a call that marks it down.

Window: 1826 days from the call.

The spread did not go the way the call said. Miss.

The grader’s working: R6 RELATIVE (BULLISH vs ^CNXPSUBANK): pick 1M -3.65%/3M -8.11%; comparator 1M +2.85%/3M -0.46%; spread 1M -6.50% (AGAINST-direction), 3M -7.64% (AGAINST-direction) -> MISS.

Read the original articleSee Pramod Gubbi’s full track record