SV

Street Verdict

Analyst Scorecard

A record of what Aditya Shah said publicly, with the source. Not advice.

“Aditya Shah ranks TCS as his top pick in the broader IT sector based on strong business fundamentals. He also highlights HCL Tech for its attractive valuation following recent price corrections, suggesting it's a favorable entry point.”
TCSBullishCalled 23 Apr 2026Graded 21 Nov 2026
Verdict:MISS

How this relative call is judged

A relative call is a comparison, judged on closing prices from the first close after the call to the end of its window (3 months when the quote states no time frame). The spread is the pick's return minus the comparator's return: above zero is a hit for a call that favours the pick, and the reverse for a call that marks it down.

Compared with: Nifty IT.

Window: 90 days from the call.

The pick -7.87%, Nifty IT +0.07%: spread -7.94 points. The spread did not go the way the call said. Miss.

The grader’s working: R6 RELATIVE (BULLISH vs Nifty IT): pick entered ₹2396.9 on 2026-04-24, Nifty IT entered ₹28530.6 on 2026-04-24; to 2026-07-22: pick -7.87% vs Nifty IT +0.07%, spread -7.94 points -> MISS (a spread above zero is a hit). No time frame stated: a relative call is judged over 3 months (90 days) from publication. Read from the quote: top pick against "Nifty IT".

Read the original articleSee Aditya Shah’s full track record